Identifying
Trust Issues in the Present
Are there any connections between the ways you were betrayed before or during
your trauma and the difficulties you have trusting others in the present? Can
you identify any relationships in the present where you have trust issues that
originated in the trauma or in secondary world experiences?
Use
the following sentence as a model: Because I was betrayed by the U.S. military,
who did not protect New York City, I now distrust my safety and have strong reactions
when I hear sirens.
Exercise:
Assessing Trustworthiness In a previous exercise, you identified three
persons who betrayed you in the past and the ways in which those three betrayals
affected your current relationships. In the following exercise, you are asked
to do something more complicated: to assess the trustworthiness of three persons
from your present-day life, given the information you currently have.
Consider
the following questions: Do you mistrust this person totally, or do you
trust him/or her in some areas, but not others? What evidence do you have
that it is safe to trust the person in these areas? What evidence do you have
to the contrary? What else would you need to know to put your trust in this
person in the areas you specified? Is it possible to find out this information?
For example, are there other people you can talk to about this person? Are
there written records you can examine? Are there questions you can ask this
person? Is there a safe way to test whether your evaluation of
this person is accurate?
Your
writings about each relationship should address each of the following categories: Initial Impressions Check and complete as many items as apply: I
do not trust _____ in the following areas _____. I do trust _____ in the following
areas _____. I dont trust _____ in any way. I trust _____ totally.
Assessing
Trustworthiness: Analyzing Initial Impressions and Information I have
seen, heard, and sensed the following about this person. In the past, this person
has _____, _____, and _____. At this point in time, the following information
indicates this person might be trustworthy because _____. At this point in
time, the following information indicates this person is not trustworthy because
_____. At this point in time, most of the information suggests _____ about
this persons trustworthiness. I trust this person in the areas of _____
and _____ and _____ because _____. In order to be more certain about my trust,
I need to find out _____. I do not trust this person in the following areas
_____. The reasons I dont trust this person in these areas is because
I have seen, heard, and sensed the following about this person _____. In the
past this person has _____.
Obtaining
Additional Information and Checking Out Reality With whom can I talk to
obtain more information about this person? Is there someone whose opinion
I respect with whom I can check my perceptions and who can help me sort out the
information I do have about this person?
Hypothesis
Testing: Devising Experiments to Test Someone: Taking Small Manageable Chances
to Find Out More Information Is there a safe, doable experiment I can
devise to test whether this person is caring and trustworthy or to test other
thoughts I have about him/her? Is there some smaller step I can take toward
trusting that person that will not be too costly to me and that will help me to
judge that persons trustworthiness? What small step might that be? Whats
the worst thing that might happen? If taking this small step seems extremely
risky, then why am I contemplating it?
Revising
Your Hypotheses Or Thoughts About Someone Assuming you have taken that
small chance and observed that persons reaction, what did you learn about
him/her? How does this change your previous evaluation of this person? Can
you take another small step toward trusting him/her, or did the information you
obtained show you that you need to be cautious? If this person disappointed
you, does this mean that he/she is not to be trusted at all or that there are
additional areas where this person isnt to be trusted? If so, what
are these areas? If you learned that this person could be trusted just a little
more, does it make sense to take another small step toward trusting him/her a
little more and see what happens? With whom can you talk to help you analyze
and sort out what you learned about this person?
Revised
Current Impressions Check and complete as many items as apply. Then, compare
your current assessment of the person under consideration with your initial assessment.
Congratulations on having taken the time and effort to think through issues of
trust with this relationship. How do you feel having completed all of this work?
Hopefully, you will feel that you now have a little more control of the relationship. I
do not trust _____ in the following areas _____. I do trust _____ in the following
areas _____. I dont trust _____ in any way. I trust _____ totally. I
am still uncertain about the following with respect to this person _____. I still
need to find out _____. The steps I need to take to find out what I need to
know are _____, _____, and _____.
Areas
of Uncertainty I am not sure whether or not to trust _____ in the following
areas _____, ______, _____, and _____. The reasons I might not trust are _____.
The reason I have to be cautious are _____. What I need to know to make
a good decision is _____. I can find out some of what I need to know by taking
the following steps: _____.
Some areas I might never be sure about are _____.
Personal
Reflection Exercise #3 The preceding section contained worksheets for
client self-assessment. Write two case study examples regarding possible applications
of these assessments.
Update Trauma and Trust: How War Exposure Shapes Social and Institutional Trust Among Refugees
Hall, J., & Werner, K. (2022). Trauma and Trust: How War Exposure Shapes Social and Institutional Trust Among Refugees. Frontiers in psychology, 13, 786838. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.786838
Peer-Reviewed Journal Article References:
Himmerich, S. J., Ellis, R. A., & Orcutt, H. K. (2020). Application of PTSD alcohol expectancy symptom clusters to the four-dimensional model of PTSD: Support from moderations of the association between symptoms of posttraumatic stress and alcohol use. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 12(4), 347–355.
Saltzman, L. Y. (2019). It’s about time: Reconceptualizing the role of time in loss and trauma.Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 11(6), 663–670.
Taylor, S., Charura, D., Williams, G., Shaw, M., Allan, J., Cohen, E., Meth, F., & O'Dwyer, L. (2020). Loss, grief, and growth: An interpretative phenomenological analysis of experiences of trauma in asylum seekers and refugees.Traumatology. Advance online publication.
QUESTION
9 PTSD victims of terrorism and other traumas may have problems with trust.
What is a question you might have the client use for "checking out reality?" To
select and enter your answer go to Test.